I read an article called “Online Shopping, With Sales Tax
Added” by Anne Carnes. It was about a new proposed law that is currently going
through Senate, which would add a sales tax to merchandise purchased online. It
discussed why they were adding this tax onto merchandise, and which states were
for the tax. The article said that it is supported by “some
revenue-hungry states, as well as brick and mortar merchants who say it would
eliminate an unfair advantage for online sellers.” This shows that the author might
be against the tax, because of the negative connotations that she placed on the
states that support it. I think the overall main idea of this text was that the
tax is unnecessary, and takes away a lot of what made online shopping
attractive to many shoppers. The author gave details about the history of this
subject, and this helped support the main idea by giving background information
to help the reader understand why the author disagrees with it.
The author wants the reader to think that the
new sales tax is unnecessary and partially defeats the purpose of shopping
online. The author does this by using adjectives with negative connotations to
describe the law. For example, she said “If the proposal becomes law, a perk of
online shopping would go away and shoppers would pay the sales taxes to the
online retailer at the time of purchase — just as they do now in physical
stores.” This is showing how it is taking away some of the charm and simplicity
of online shopping, and the author wants the reader to agree. The craft moves
also include that the author included quotes from people who had a similar
opinion as her, to show that it was more than just her bias. This worked to
make it seem more reliable and also made her thesis seem stronger.
Now that I have read this article, I will pay
more attention to the websites that will charge sales tax. It also helped me
think more about the commercial goals of many companies, and given me a
different view of online shopping, and shopping in general. I will now think
more critically about the merchandise I am buying, and where it is coming from.
I would like to learn further about what caused this sudden change, and why
this tax will be added. I now think of online shopping as more than just an
easy way to consume, but as another way that companies are manipulating people.